Development Management Sub-Committee - 17 August 2016 - Wednesday, 17th August 2016 at 10:00am - City of Edinburgh Council Webcasts

Development Management Sub-Committee - 17 August 2016
Wednesday, 17th August 2016 at 10:00am 

Agenda

Slides

Transcript

Map

Resources

Forums

Speakers

Votes

 
Start of webcast
Share this agenda point
  1. The meeting is due to start at 10am
  2. Slide 1Slide 1
  3. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  4. Mr Stephen Broughton (Clerk)
1.1 Order of Business
Share this agenda point
  1. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  2. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
2.1 Declarations of Interest
Share this agenda point
  1. Mr Stephen Broughton (Clerk)
  2. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  3. Mr Stephen Broughton (Clerk)
  4. Cllr Nick Gardner (Labour)
  5. Cllr Nick Gardner (Labour)
  6. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  7. Mr Stephen Broughton (Clerk)
3.1 Minutes
Share this agenda point
  1. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  2. Mr Stephen Broughton (Clerk)
  3. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  4. Mr Stephen Broughton (Clerk)
6.1(a) - Protocol Note – report by the Interim Head of Strategy and Insight (circulated)
Share this agenda point
6.1(b) - 18 Whitehouse Road, Edinburgh – Proposed demolition of existing dwelling and construction of new care home and associated car parking (as amended)
6.1(c) - 18 Whitehouse Road, Edinburgh – Demolition of dwelling in a conservation area
Share this agenda point
  1. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  2. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  3. Planning Officer
6.1(a) - Protocol Note – report by the Interim Head of Strategy and Insight (circulated)
Share this agenda point
6.1(c) - 18 Whitehouse Road, Edinburgh – Demolition of dwelling in a conservation area
Share this agenda point
  1. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  2. Planning Officer
  3. Slide 2Slide 2
  4. Slide 3Slide 3
  5. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  6. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  7. Cllr Karen Keil (Labour)
  8. Planning Officer
  9. Cllr Karen Keil (Labour)
  10. Planning Officer
  11. Planning Officer
  12. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  13. Mr Stephen Broughton (Clerk)
  14. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  15. Deputation Public Speaker
  16. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  17. Deputation Public Speaker
  18. Slide 4Slide 4
  19. Slide 5Slide 5
  20. Slide 6Slide 6
  21. Slide 7Slide 7
  22. Slide 8Slide 8
  23. Slide 9Slide 9
  24. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  25. Deputation Public Speaker
  26. Deputation Public Speaker
  27. Slide 10Slide 10
  28. Slide 11Slide 11
  29. Slide 12Slide 12
  30. Slide 13Slide 13
  31. Slide 14Slide 14
  32. Slide 15Slide 15
  33. Slide 16Slide 16
  34. Slide 17Slide 17
  35. Slide 18Slide 18
  36. Slide 19Slide 19
  37. Slide 20Slide 20
  38. Slide 21Slide 21
  39. Slide 22Slide 22
  40. Slide 23Slide 23
  41. Slide 24Slide 24
  42. Slide 25Slide 25
  43. Slide 26Slide 26
  44. Slide 27Slide 27
  45. Slide 28Slide 28
  46. Slide 29Slide 29
  47. Slide 30Slide 30
  48. Slide 31Slide 31
  49. Slide 32Slide 32
  50. Slide 33Slide 33
  51. Slide 34Slide 34
  52. Slide 35Slide 35
  53. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  54. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  55. Slide 36Slide 36
  56. Cllr Joanna Mowat (Conservative)
  57. Slide 37Slide 37
6.1(b) - 18 Whitehouse Road, Edinburgh – Proposed demolition of existing dwelling and construction of new care home and associated car parking (as amended)
Share this agenda point
  1. Deputation Public Speaker
  2. Slide 38Slide 38
  3. Slide 39Slide 39
  4. Slide 40Slide 40
  5. Slide 41Slide 41
  6. Cllr Joanna Mowat (Conservative)
  7. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  8. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  9. Slide 42Slide 42
  10. Deputation Public Speaker
  11. Slide 43Slide 43
  12. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  13. Slide 44Slide 44
  14. Deputation Public Speaker
  15. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  16. Cllr Angela Blacklock (Labour)
  17. Slide 45Slide 45
  18. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  19. Slide 46Slide 46
  20. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  21. Deputation Public Speaker
  22. Cllr Lewis Ritchie (EPIC)
  23. Cllr Lewis Ritchie (EPIC)
  24. Slide 47Slide 47
  25. Deputation Public Speaker
  26. Deputation Public Speaker
  27. Slide 48Slide 48
  28. Slide 49Slide 49
  29. Slide 50Slide 50
  30. Slide 51Slide 51
  31. Slide 52Slide 52
  32. Cllr Lewis Ritchie (EPIC)
  33. Slide 53Slide 53
  34. Slide 54Slide 54
  35. Cllr Lewis Ritchie (EPIC)
  36. Deputation Public Speaker
  37. Slide 55Slide 55
  38. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  39. Slide 56Slide 56
  40. Slide 57Slide 57
  41. Deputation Public Speaker
  42. Slide 58Slide 58
  43. Slide 59Slide 59
  44. Slide 60Slide 60
  45. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  46. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  47. Cllr Angela Blacklock (Labour)
  48. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  49. Slide 61Slide 61
  50. Cllr Maureen Child (Labour)
  51. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  52. Slide 62Slide 62
  53. Slide 63Slide 63
  54. Mr Stephen Broughton (Clerk)
  55. Slide 64Slide 64
  56. Slide 65Slide 65
  57. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  58. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  59. Deputation Public Speaker
  60. Deputation Public Speaker
  61. Slide 66Slide 66
  62. Slide 67Slide 67
  63. Slide 68Slide 68
  64. Slide 69Slide 69
  65. Slide 70Slide 70
  66. Slide 71Slide 71
  67. Slide 72Slide 72
  68. Slide 73Slide 73
  69. Slide 74Slide 74
  70. Slide 75Slide 75
  71. Slide 76Slide 76
  72. Slide 77Slide 77
  73. Slide 78Slide 78
  74. Deputation Public Speaker
  75. Slide 79Slide 79
  76. Slide 80Slide 80
  77. Slide 81Slide 81
  78. Slide 82Slide 82
  79. Slide 83Slide 83
  80. Slide 84Slide 84
  81. Slide 85Slide 85
  82. Slide 86Slide 86
  83. Slide 87Slide 87
  84. Slide 88Slide 88
  85. Slide 89Slide 89
  86. Slide 90Slide 90
  87. Slide 91Slide 91
  88. Slide 92Slide 92
  89. Slide 93Slide 93
  90. Slide 94Slide 94
  91. Slide 95Slide 95
  92. Slide 96Slide 96
  93. Slide 97Slide 97
  94. Slide 98Slide 98
  95. Slide 99Slide 99
  96. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  97. Cllr Nick Gardner (Labour)
  98. Cllr Nick Gardner (Labour)
  99. Slide 100Slide 100
  100. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  101. Deputation Public Speaker
  102. Slide 101Slide 101
  103. Slide 102Slide 102
  104. Slide 103Slide 103
  105. Slide 104Slide 104
  106. Slide 105Slide 105
  107. Slide 106Slide 106
  108. Slide 107Slide 107
  109. Slide 108Slide 108
  110. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  111. Slide 109Slide 109
  112. Deputation Public Speaker
  113. Slide 110Slide 110
  114. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  115. Mr Stephen Broughton (Clerk)
  116. Slide 111Slide 111
  117. Slide 112Slide 112
  118. Deputation Public Speaker
  119. Slide 113Slide 113
  120. Cllr Norman Work (Scottish National Party)
  121. Deputation Public Speaker
  122. Slide 114Slide 114
  123. Slide 115Slide 115
  124. Slide 116Slide 116
  125. Slide 117Slide 117
  126. Slide 118Slide 118
  127. Cllr Norman Work (Scottish National Party)
  128. Cllr Norman Work (Scottish National Party)
  129. Slide 119Slide 119
  130. Slide 120Slide 120
  131. Slide 121Slide 121
  132. Slide 122Slide 122
  133. Slide 123Slide 123
  134. Slide 124Slide 124
  135. Slide 125Slide 125
  136. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  137. Cllr Karen Keil (Labour)
  138. Cllr Norman Work (Scottish National Party)
  139. Cllr Lewis Ritchie (EPIC)
  140. Slide 126Slide 126
  141. Slide 127Slide 127
  142. Slide 128Slide 128
  143. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  144. Cllr Norman Work (Scottish National Party)
  145. Cllr Lewis Ritchie (EPIC)
  146. Cllr Lewis Ritchie (EPIC)
  147. Slide 129Slide 129
  148. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  149. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  150. Mr Stephen Broughton (Clerk)
  151. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  152. Mr Stephen Broughton (Clerk)
  153. Slide 130Slide 130
  154. Deputation Public Speaker
  155. Slide 131Slide 131
  156. Slide 132Slide 132
  157. Slide 133Slide 133
  158. Slide 134Slide 134
  159. Slide 135Slide 135
  160. Slide 136Slide 136
  161. Slide 137Slide 137
  162. Slide 138Slide 138
  163. Slide 139Slide 139
  164. Slide 140Slide 140
  165. Slide 141Slide 141
  166. Slide 142Slide 142
  167. Slide 143Slide 143
  168. Slide 144Slide 144
  169. Slide 145Slide 145
  170. Slide 146Slide 146
  171. Slide 147Slide 147
  172. Slide 148Slide 148
  173. Slide 149Slide 149
  174. Slide 150Slide 150
  175. Slide 151Slide 151
  176. Slide 152Slide 152
  177. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  178. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  179. Cllr Nick Gardner (Labour)
  180. Slide 153Slide 153
  181. Deputation Public Speaker
  182. Slide 154Slide 154
  183. Slide 155Slide 155
  184. Cllr Maureen Child (Labour)
  185. Slide 156Slide 156
  186. Slide 157Slide 157
  187. Deputation Public Speaker
  188. Deputation Public Speaker
  189. Slide 158Slide 158
  190. Slide 159Slide 159
  191. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  192. Deputation Public Speaker
  193. Slide 160Slide 160
  194. Slide 161Slide 161
  195. Slide 162Slide 162
  196. Slide 163Slide 163
4.1 - 18 Cambridge Avenue, Edinburgh – New house extension to the garden with external steps – application no 16/02622/FUL – report by the Head of Planning and Transport
Share this agenda point
  1. Slide 164Slide 164
  2. Slide 165Slide 165
  3. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  4. Cllr Karen Keil (Labour)
  5. Deputation Public Speaker
  6. Deputation Public Speaker
  7. Cllr Lewis Ritchie (EPIC)
  8. Slide 166Slide 166
  9. Deputation Public Speaker
  10. Slide 167Slide 167
  11. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  12. Slide 168Slide 168
  13. Cllr Lewis Ritchie (EPIC)
  14. Deputation Public Speaker
  15. Cllr Lewis Ritchie (EPIC)
  16. Cllr Lewis Ritchie (EPIC)
  17. Deputation Public Speaker
  18. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  19. Cllr Joanna Mowat (Conservative)
  20. Deputation Public Speaker
  21. Slide 169Slide 169
  22. Deputation Public Speaker
  23. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  24. Deputation Public Speaker
  25. Deputation Public Speaker
  26. Slide 170Slide 170
  27. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  28. Cllr Maureen Child (Labour)
  29. Slide 171Slide 171
  30. Slide 172Slide 172
  31. Slide 173Slide 173
  32. Deputation Public Speaker
  33. Deputation Public Speaker
  34. Slide 174Slide 174
  35. Slide 175Slide 175
  36. Slide 176Slide 176
  37. Slide 177Slide 177
  38. Slide 178Slide 178
  39. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  40. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  41. Cllr Steve Burgess (Scottish Green)
  42. Deputation Public Speaker
  43. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  44. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  45. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  46. Cllr Angela Blacklock (Labour)
  47. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
9.1 - 1 Craigpark Ratho Newbridge (Craigpark Quarry) – Forthcoming application by Alex Brewster And Sons for restoration of former Craigpark Quarry for outdoor countryside and water related leisure and recreation
Share this agenda point
  1. Planning Officer
  2. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  3. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  4. Cllr Joanna Mowat (Conservative)
  5. Cllr Joanna Mowat (Conservative)
  6. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  7. Cllr Joanna Mowat (Conservative)
  8. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  9. Planning Officer
  10. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  11. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  12. Cllr Maureen Child (Labour)
  13. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  14. Cllr Maureen Child (Labour)
  15. Cllr Lewis Ritchie (EPIC)
  16. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  17. Cllr Alex Lunn (Scottish National Party)
  18. Cllr Joanna Mowat (Conservative)
  19. Cllr Joanna Mowat (Conservative)
  20. Cllr Alex Lunn (Scottish National Party)
  21. Cllr Joanna Mowat (Conservative)
  22. Cllr Alex Lunn (Scottish National Party)
  23. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  24. Cllr Steve Burgess (Scottish Green)
  25. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  26. Cllr Alex Lunn (Scottish National Party)
  27. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  28. Mr Stephen Broughton (Clerk)
  29. Mr Stephen Broughton (Clerk)
  30. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  31. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  32. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  33. Cllr Angela Blacklock (Labour)
  34. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  35. Planning Officer
  36. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  37. Planning Officer
  38. Planning Officer
  39. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  40. Planning Officer
  41. Planning Officer
  42. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  43. Planning Officer
  44. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  45. Planning Officer
  46. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  47. Planning Officer
  48. Planning Officer
  49. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  50. Planning Officer
  51. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  52. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  53. Cllr Karen Keil (Labour)
  54. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  55. Cllr Karen Keil (Labour)
  56. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  57. Cllr Alex Lunn (Scottish National Party)
  58. Cllr Joanna Mowat (Conservative)
  59. Cllr Joanna Mowat (Conservative)
  60. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  61. Planning Officer
  62. Planning Officer
  63. Cllr Joanna Mowat (Conservative)
  64. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  65. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  66. Cllr Karen Keil (Labour)
  67. Cllr Karen Keil (Labour)
  68. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  69. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  70. Cllr Nick Gardner (Labour)
  71. Cllr Nick Gardner (Labour)
  72. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  73. Cllr Nick Gardner (Labour)
  74. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  75. Cllr Nick Gardner (Labour)
  76. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  77. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  78. Cllr Alex Lunn (Scottish National Party)
  79. Cllr Alex Lunn (Scottish National Party)
  80. Cllr Nick Gardner (Labour)
  81. Planning Officer
  82. Cllr Nick Gardner (Labour)
  83. Cllr Nick Gardner (Labour)
  84. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  85. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  86. Planning Officer
  87. Planning Officer
  88. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  89. Cllr Karen Keil (Labour)
  90. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  91. Planning Officer
  92. Cllr Lewis Ritchie (EPIC)
  93. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  94. Mr Stephen Broughton (Clerk)
  95. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  96. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  97. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  98. Mr Stephen Broughton (Clerk)
  99. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  100. Mr Stephen Broughton (Clerk)
  101. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  102. Planning Officer
7.1(a) - 5 - 7 Regent Road (New Parliament House) – Project proposes conservation of Thomas Hamilton designed former Royal High School building to form new premises for St Mary's Music School
Share this agenda point
  1. Planning Officer
  2. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  3. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  4. Mr Stephen Broughton (Clerk)
  5. Mr Stephen Broughton (Clerk)
  6. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  7. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  8. Cllr Angela Blacklock (Labour)
  9. Mr Stephen Broughton (Clerk)
  10. Mr Stephen Broughton (Clerk)
  11. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  12. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  13. Planning Officer
  14. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  15. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  16. Cllr Dominic Heslop (Conservative)
  17. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  18. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  19. Cllr Joanna Mowat (Conservative)
  20. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  21. Planning Officer
  22. Planning Officer
  23. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  24. Cllr Joanna Mowat (Conservative)
  25. Cllr Joanna Mowat (Conservative)
  26. Planning Officer
  27. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  28. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  29. Cllr Joanna Mowat (Conservative)
  30. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  31. Mr Stephen Broughton (Clerk)
  32. Mr Stephen Broughton (Clerk)
  33. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  34. Mr Stephen Broughton (Clerk)
  35. Mr Stephen Broughton (Clerk)
  36. Planning Officer
7.2 - 65 West Harbour Road, Edinburgh – Approval of matters specified in condition 2 of outline application 01/00802/OUT
Share this agenda point
  1. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  2. Mr Stephen Broughton (Clerk)
  3. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  4. Mr Stephen Broughton (Clerk)
  5. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  6. Planning Officer
  7. Planning Officer
  8. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  9. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  10. Cllr Angela Blacklock (Labour)
  11. Planning Officer
  12. Planning Officer
  13. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  14. Cllr Angela Blacklock (Labour)
  15. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  16. Planning Officer
  17. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  18. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  19. Planning Officer
  20. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  21. Cllr Lewis Ritchie (EPIC)
  22. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  23. Cllr Joanna Mowat (Conservative)
  24. Cllr Lewis Ritchie (EPIC)
  25. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  26. Cllr Angela Blacklock (Labour)
  27. Cllr Ian Perry (Labour)
  28. Cllr Angela Blacklock (Labour)
  29. Cllr Lewis Ritchie (EPIC)
  30. Cllr Alex Lunn (Scottish National Party)
  31. Cllr Ronald Cairns (Scottish National Party)