Culture and Communities Committee - Thursday 10 August 2023, 10:00am - Start video at 0:21:25 - City of Edinburgh Council Webcasts
			Culture and Communities Committee
Thursday, 10th August 2023 at 10:00am 
		
			Speaking:  
				
					
									Agenda item : 
									Start of webcast								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Val Walker
									Agenda item : 
									1. Order of Business								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
									Agenda item : 
									1 a) Order of Business								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Val Walker
									Agenda item : 
									2. Declaration of Interests								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
									2 a) Declaration of Interests								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
									Agenda item : 
									3. Deputations								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
									3 a) Deputations								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Deputation
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Deputation
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Deputation
- 
											Cllr Marie-Clair Munro
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Marie-Clair Munro
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Deputation
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Deputation
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Deputation
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
									Agenda item : 
									4. Minutes								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
									4 a) Minutes								
							
									Agenda item : 
									4 b) Minutes								
							
									Agenda item : 
									5. Forward Planning								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
									5 a) Work Programme								
							
									Agenda item : 
									5 b) Rolling Actions Log								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
									Agenda item : 
									6. Business Bulletin								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
									6 a) Business Bulletin								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Edward Thornley
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Edward Thornley
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Joan Parr
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Dan Heap
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
									Agenda item : 
									7. Executive Decisions								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
									7 a) Police Scotland – Edinburgh City Division Scrutiny Report – April 2022 to March 2023								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Police Scotland
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Police Scotland
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Police Scotland
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Alex Staniforth
- 
											Police Scotland
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Police Scotland
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Police Scotland
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Police Scotland
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Police Scotland
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Police Scotland
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Police Scotland
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Marie-Clair Munro
- 
											Police Scotland
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Dan Heap
- 
											Police Scotland
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
									Agenda item : 
									7 a) Police Scotland – Edinburgh City Division Scrutiny Report – April 2022 to March 2023								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Val Walker
									Agenda item : 
									7 b) Scottish Fire and Rescue Service – Local Plan Performance Report – City of Edinburgh – April 2022 to March 2023								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Dan Heap
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Edward Thornley
- 
											Cllr Edward Thornley
- 
											Cllr Edward Thornley
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
									Agenda item : 
									7 c) Response to Motion by Councillor Heap - Concessionary Tickets Schemes for Cultural Events								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Dan Heap
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Max Mitchell
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Dan Heap
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Dan Heap
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Edward Thornley
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Dan Heap
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Dan Heap
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Alex Staniforth
- 
											Cllr Dan Heap
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Max Mitchell
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Dan Heap
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
									Agenda item : 
									7 d) Response to Motion by Councillor McFarlane - Save the Filmhouse								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
- 
											Joan Parr
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
									Agenda item : 
									7 e) Response to Motion by Councillor Campbell - Lifelong Learning Review								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Alex Staniforth
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Edward Thornley
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
									Agenda item : 
									7 f) Meadows Jawbone Arch Conservation Project								
							
									Agenda item : 
									7 f) Meadows Jawbone Arch Conservation Project								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Dan Heap
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Dan Heap
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Alex Staniforth
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Max Mitchell
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Max Mitchell
- 
											Cllr Marie-Clair Munro
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Alex Staniforth
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Alex Staniforth
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
									Agenda item : 
									7 g) Delivering the 20-Minute Neighbourhood Strategy - Update								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Alex Staniforth
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Marie-Clair Munro
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Marie-Clair Munro
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Marie-Clair Munro
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Max Mitchell
- 
											Cllr Max Mitchell
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Dan Heap
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
									Agenda item : 
									7 h) Response to Motion by Councillor O'Neill - Edinburgh's Monuments and Commemoration								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Gareth Barwell
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Dan Heap
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Edward Thornley
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Max Mitchell
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Marie-Clair Munro
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
									Agenda item : 
									7 h) Response to Motion by Councillor O'Neill - Edinburgh's Monuments and Commemoration								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
									Agenda item : 
									8. Routine Decisions								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
									8 a) Edinburgh’s Winter Festivals – Update on Procurement								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Max Mitchell
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Dan Heap
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Fiona Glasgow
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Edward Thornley
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Dan Heap
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Alex Staniforth
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Max Mitchell
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
									Agenda item : 
									8 b) Parks and Openspace Investment Update								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Alex Staniforth
- 
											Gareth Barwell
- 
											Gareth Barwell
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Edward Thornley
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Max Mitchell
- 
											Cllr Max Mitchell
- 
											Gareth Barwell
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Edward Thornley
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Dan Heap
									Agenda item : 
									8 c) Response to Motion by Councillor Heap - Library Collection Development (Reflecting Edinburgh’s National, Ethnic and Linguistic Diversity)								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Dan Heap
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
									Agenda item : 
									9. Motions								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
									9 a) By Councillor McFarlane - Closure of The Nelson Monument								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Fiona Glasgow
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
									Agenda item : 
									9 b) By Councillor Osler - Fire Service								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Edward Thornley
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Edward Thornley
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Edward Thornley
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
- 
											Lesley Birrell (Clerk)
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Lesley Birrell (Clerk)
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Lesley Birrell (Clerk)
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
- 
											Lesley Birrell (Clerk)
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
									Agenda item : 
									9 c) By Councillor Thornley - Green Flag Awards								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
- 
											Cllr Edward Thornley
- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
									Agenda item : 
									9 d) By Councillor Thornley - Community Centre Strategy Reporting								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Edward Thornley
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
									Agenda item : 
									9 e) By Councillor Nicolson - Crewe Toll Fire Station (Turntable Ladder)								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
									Agenda item : 
									9 f) By Councillor Parker - Grass Cutting Standards								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Alex Staniforth
- 
											Cllr Edward Thornley
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Dan Heap
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
									Agenda item : 
									9 g) By Councillor Caldwell - Montgomery Street Park Helter Skelter								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Daniel Baigrie (Clerk)
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Edward Thornley
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Cllr Val Walker
- 
											Webcast Finished
- Item 4.1 - Minute 11 May 2023, opens in new tab
- Item 4.2 - Minute of 8 June 2023, opens in new tab
- Item 5.1 - Work Programme, opens in new tab
- Item 5.2 - Rolling Actions Log, opens in new tab
- Item 6.1 - Business Bulletin - August 2023, opens in new tab
- Item 7.1 - Police Scotland – Edinburgh City Division Scrutiny Report – April 2022 to March 2023, opens in new tab
- Item 7.2 - Scottish Fire and Rescue Service – Local Plan Performance Report – City of Edinburgh – April 2022 to March 2023, opens in new tab
- Item 7.3 - Response to Motion by Councillor Heap Concessionary Ticket Schemes for Cultural Events, opens in new tab
- Item 7.4 - Response to Motion by Councillor McFarlane – Save the Filmhouse, opens in new tab
- Item 7.5 - Response to Motion by Councillor Campbell - Lifelong Learning Review, opens in new tab
- Item 7.6 - Meadows Jawbone Arch Conservation Project, opens in new tab
- Item 7.7 - Delivering the 20-Minute Neighbourhood Strategy - Update, opens in new tab
- Item 7.8 - Response to Motion by Councillor O'Neill - Edinburgh's Monuments and Commemoration, opens in new tab
- Item 8.1 - Edinburgh’s Winter Festivals – Update on Procurement, opens in new tab
- Item 8.2 - Parks and Openspace Investment Update, opens in new tab
- Item 8.3 - Response to Motion by Councillor Heap - Library Collection Development (Reflecting Edinburgh’s National, Ethnic and Linguistic Diversity, opens in new tab
- Item 3 - Deputations, opens in new tab
- Motions and Amendments Full Pack, opens in new tab
 
																									 
																									
															Scottish National Party														
													 
																									
															Scottish Green Party														
													 
																									 
																									
															Scottish National Party														
													 
																									
															Scottish Conservatives														
													 
																									
															Scottish Conservatives														
													 
																									
															Scottish Liberal Democrats														
													 
																									 
																									
															Scottish Green Party														
													 
																									
															Scottish Liberal Democrats														
													 
																									
															Scottish Labour