Development Management Sub-Committee - Wednesday 4 October 2023, 10:00am - Start video at 0:08:54 - City of Edinburgh Council Webcasts
			Development Management Sub-Committee
Wednesday, 4th October 2023 at 10:00am 
		
			Speaking:  
				
					
									Agenda item : 
									Start of webcast								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Taylor Ward (Committee Clerk)
									Agenda item : 
									1. Order of business								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
									1 a) Order of Business								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
									2. Declaration of interests								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Chas Booth
- 
											Paul Devaney
- 
											Cllr Chas Booth
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Paul Devaney
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Chas Booth
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Taylor Ward (Committee Clerk)
									Agenda item : 
									2 a) Declaration of interests								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Taylor Ward (Committee Clerk)
									Agenda item : 
									3. Minutes								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
									3 a) Minutes								
							
									Agenda item : 
									4. General Applications, Miscellaneous Business and Pre-Application Reports								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Taylor Ward (Committee Clerk)
									Agenda item : 
																	
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
									4 a) Report for forthcoming application by Glencairn Property for Proposal of Application Notice at 185-187 Dundee Street & 5/5 Dundee Terrace, Edinburgh - Purpose built student accommodation, retail/commercial space and associated works - application no. 23/03685/PAN - Report by the Chief Planning Officer								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
									Agenda item : 
									4 b) 52 Eyre Place, Edinburgh - Change of use from residential to short-term holiday let accommodation - retrospective - application no. 23/02813/FULSTL - Report by the Chief Planning Officer								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Taylor Ward (Committee Clerk)
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
									Agenda item : 
									4 c) Oxcars Court and Inchmickery Court, Muirhouse Grove, Edinburgh - Proposed thermal and material improvements (including repairs and maintenance) to both Oxcars Court and Inchmickery Court. Works also include the creation of a residents Heart Space (potential uses TBC but may contain Class 1; Class 3; Class 9 and/or Class 10) plus associated landscaping improvement works (as amended) - application no. 23/01118/FUL - Report by the Chief Planning Officer								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Taylor Ward (Committee Clerk)
									Agenda item : 
									4 d) Development North of Inchgarvie Lodge, Society Road, Port Edgar - Conversion of existing listed buildings to 49 residential units, cafe/restaurant, and services apartment - application no. 22/01987/FUL - Report by the Chief Planning Officer								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
											
									Agenda item : 
									4 e) Development North of Inchgarvie Lodge, Society Road, Port Edgar - Conversion of existing listed buildings to 49 residential units, cafe/restaurant and services apartment, with associated demolition and new works - application no. 22/02047/LBC - Report by the Chief Planning Officer								
							
									Agenda item : 
									4 f) Garage 20 Metres East of 21 St Catherine's Place, Edinburgh - Change of use of ancillary domestic garage to short term let (Sui Generis), and external alterations - application no. 23/02361/FULSTL - Report by the Chief Planning Officer								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
											
									Agenda item : 
									5. Returning Applications								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
																	
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
									5 a) 7 Murrayburn Gate, Edinburgh, EH14 2SS - Proposed affordable housing development comprising 73 units with associated infrastructure and landscape - application no. 22/03302/FUL - Report by the Chief Planning Officer								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Paul Devaney
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Taylor Ward (Committee Clerk)
									Agenda item : 
									6. Applications for Hearing								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
																	
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
									6 a) None.								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
									7. Applications for Detailed Presentation								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
																	
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
									7 a) 104-106, 107 & 108 Princes Street, Edinburgh, EH2 3AA - Redevelopment including demolition for hotel use (Class 7) with ancillary bar/restaurant facilities and retail use at basement and ground levels including associated alterations and extensions (As amended) - application 23/01417/FUL - Report by the Chief Planning Officer								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Tim Jones
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Alan Beal
- 
											Cllr Alan Beal
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr James Dalgleish
- 
											Cllr James Dalgleish
- 
											Cllr James Dalgleish
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Neil Gardiner
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Neil Gardiner
- 
											Cllr Martha Mattos Coelho
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Chas Booth
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Chas Booth
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Alan Beal
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Neil Gardiner
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Neil Gardiner
- 
											Cllr Neil Gardiner
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Chas Booth
- 
											Paul Devaney
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr James Dalgleish
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Martha Mattos Coelho
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Alan Beal
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Neil Gardiner
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Chas Booth
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Taylor Ward (Committee Clerk)
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Tim Jones
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Neil Gardiner
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Neil Gardiner
- 
											Cllr Chas Booth
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Chas Booth
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Chas Booth
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Neil Gardiner
- 
											Cllr Chas Booth
- 
											Paul Devaney
- 
											Taylor Ward (Committee Clerk)
- 
											Taylor Ward (Committee Clerk)
- 
											Taylor Ward (Committee Clerk)
- 
											Taylor Ward (Committee Clerk)
- 
											Taylor Ward (Committee Clerk)
- 
											Taylor Ward (Committee Clerk)
									Agenda item : 
									7 b) 104-105 Princes Street, Edinburgh, EH2 3AA - Internal and external alterations including partial demolition and rear extension to form new hotel (as amended) - application no. 23/01420/LBC - Report by the Chief Planning Officer								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Chas Booth
- 
											Paul Devaney
- 
											Cllr Chas Booth
- 
											Paul Devaney
- 
											Paul Devaney
- 
											Cllr Chas Booth
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Neil Gardiner
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Taylor Ward (Committee Clerk)
- 
											Taylor Ward (Committee Clerk)
- 
											Taylor Ward (Committee Clerk)
- 
											Taylor Ward (Committee Clerk)
- 
											Taylor Ward (Committee Clerk)
									Agenda item : 
									7 c) 106 Princes Street, Edinburgh, EH2 3AA - Internal and external alterations, including partial demolition and rear extension, to form new hotel (as amended) - application no. 23/01422/LBC - Report by the Chief Planning Officer								
							
									Agenda item : 
									7 d) 107-108 Princes Street, Edinburgh, EH2 3AA - Demolition of retail and office building - application no. 23/01425/CON - Report by the Chief Planning Officer								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Taylor Ward (Committee Clerk)
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
									Agenda item : 
									7 d) 107-108 Princes Street, Edinburgh, EH2 3AA - Demolition of retail and office building - application no. 23/01425/CON - Report by the Chief Planning Officer								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Taylor Ward (Committee Clerk)
									Agenda item : 
									7 e) 181 St John's Road, Edinburgh, EH12 7SL - Application for the Modification of Planning Agreement (Section 75) associated with planning permission 18/02831/FUL. Remove clauses to provide on site affordable housing and replace these with clauses seeing to make an off-site financial contribution as the construction costs of delivering the existing consent are non-viable for affordable housing developers - application no. 22/04607/OBL - Report by the Chief Planning Officer								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Alan Beal
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Neil Gardiner
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Chas Booth
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Martha Mattos Coelho
- 
											Cllr Martha Mattos Coelho
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Chas Booth
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Margaret Arma Graham
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Alan Beal
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Alan Beal
- 
											Paul Devaney
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Paul Devaney
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Neil Gardiner
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Neil Gardiner
- 
											Paul Devaney
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Neil Gardiner
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Chas Booth
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Chas Booth
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Tim Jones
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Taylor Ward (Committee Clerk)
- 
											Taylor Ward (Committee Clerk)
- 
											Taylor Ward (Committee Clerk)
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
									Agenda item : 
									7 e) 181 St John's Road, Edinburgh, EH12 7SL - Application for the Modification of Planning Agreement (Section 75) associated with planning permission 18/02831/FUL. Remove clauses to provide on site affordable housing and replace these with clauses seeing to make an off-site financial contribution as the construction costs of delivering the existing consent are non-viable for affordable housing developers - application no. 22/04607/OBL - Report by the Chief Planning Officer								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Taylor Ward (Committee Clerk)
									Agenda item : 
									4 c) Oxcars Court and Inchmickery Court, Muirhouse Grove, Edinburgh - Proposed thermal and material improvements (including repairs and maintenance) to both Oxcars Court and Inchmickery Court. Works also include the creation of a residents Heart Space (potential uses TBC but may contain Class 1; Class 3; Class 9 and/or Class 10) plus associated landscaping improvement works (as amended) - application no. 23/01118/FUL - Report by the Chief Planning Officer								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Chas Booth
- 
											Paul Devaney
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Neil Gardiner
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Chas Booth
- 
											Paul Devaney
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Taylor Ward (Committee Clerk)
									Agenda item : 
									4 d) Development North of Inchgarvie Lodge, Society Road, Port Edgar - Conversion of existing listed buildings to 49 residential units, cafe/restaurant, and services apartment - application no. 22/01987/FUL - Report by the Chief Planning Officer								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Planning Officer
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Tim Jones
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Tim Jones
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Tim Jones
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr James Dalgleish
- 
											Cllr James Dalgleish
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Martha Mattos Coelho
- 
											Paul Devaney
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Alan Beal
- 
											Planning Officer
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Chas Booth
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Chas Booth
- 
											Paul Devaney
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Chas Booth
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Margaret Arma Graham
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Alan Beal
- 
											Cllr Alan Beal
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Chas Booth
- 
											Paul Devaney
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Paul Devaney
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Hal Osler
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Webcast Finished
- Item 3.1 - 23 August 2023, opens in new tab
- Item 4.1 - 23 03685 PAN - 185-187 Dundee Street & 4 Flat 5 Dundee Terrace, opens in new tab
- Item 4.2 - 23 02813 FULSTL - 52 Eyre Place, opens in new tab
- Item 4.3 - 23 01118 FUL - Oxcars and Inchmickery Court Muirhouse Grove, opens in new tab
- Item 4.4 - 22 01987 FUL - Port Edgar, opens in new tab
- Item 4.5 - 22 02047 LBC - Port Edgar, opens in new tab
- Item 4.6 - 23 02361 FULSTL - Garage 20 Meters East of St Catherine's Place, opens in new tab
- Item 5.1 - 22 03302 FUL - 7 Murrayburn Gate Return Report, opens in new tab
- Item 7.1 - 23 01417 FUL - 104-108 Princes Street, opens in new tab
- Item 7.2 - 23 01420 LBC - 104-105 Princes Street, opens in new tab
- Item 7.3 - 23 01422 LBC - 106 Princes Street, opens in new tab
- Item 7.4 - 23 01425 CON - 107-108 Princes Street, opens in new tab
- Item 7.5 - 22 04607 OBL - 181 St Johns Road, opens in new tab
 
																									
															Scottish Liberal Democrats														
													 
																									
															Scottish Green Party														
													 
																									
															Scottish National Party														
													 
																									
															Scottish Labour														
													 
																									
															Scottish National Party														
													 
																									
															Labour and Co-operative Party														
													 
																									
															Scottish Conservatives														
													 
																									
															Scottish Conservatives														
													 
																									
															Scottish Liberal Democrats														
													