Full Meeting Papers - Transport and Environment Committee - 06.10.2022 - Thursday 6 October 2022, 10:00am - City of Edinburgh Council Webcasts
			Full Meeting Papers - Transport and Environment Committee - 06.10.2022
Thursday, 6th October 2022 at 10:00am 
		
			Speaking:  
				
					
									Agenda item : 
									Start of webcast								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Martin Scott
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Martin Scott
									Agenda item : 
									1. Order of Business								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
									2. Declaration of Interests								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
									3. Deputations								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
									4. Minutes								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
									Agenda item : 
									3. Deputations								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Martin Scott
									Agenda item : 
									4. Minutes								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
									5. Forward Planning								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
									4. Minutes								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Martin Scott
									Agenda item : 
									1. Order of Business								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Martin Scott
									Agenda item : 
									2. Declaration of Interests								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Martin Scott
									Agenda item : 
									3. Deputations								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Martin Scott
- 
											Martin Scott
- 
											Deputation
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Deputation
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Deputation
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Deputation
- 
											Cllr Jule Bandel
- 
											Deputation
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Deputation
- 
											Cllr Sanne Dijkstra-Downie
- 
											Deputation
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Deputation
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Deputation
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Deputation
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Deputation
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Deputation
- 
											Cllr Danny Aston
- 
											Deputation
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Deputation
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Deputation
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Deputation
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Deputation
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Kevin Lang
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Kevin Lang
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Deputation
- 
											Cllr Jack Caldwell
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Jack Caldwell
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Sanne Dijkstra-Downie
- 
											Cllr Jack Caldwell
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Jack Caldwell
									Agenda item : 
									7.2 Response to Motion by Councillor Booth - Rainbow Bridge/Lindsay Road Bridge – Report by the Executive Director of Place								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Chas Booth
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Martin Scott
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Jule Bandel
- 
											Cllr Chas Booth
- 
											Martin Scott
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Kevin Lang
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Danny Aston
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Gareth Barwell
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Gareth Barwell
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Jule Bandel
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Jule Bandel
- 
											Cllr Jule Bandel
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
									Agenda item : 
									7.2 Response to Motion by Councillor Booth - Rainbow Bridge/Lindsay Road Bridge – Report by the Executive Director of Place								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Martin Scott
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Martin Scott
									Agenda item : 
									7.1 Our Future Streets: Edinburgh’s approach to a circulation plan – Report by the Executive Director of Place								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Iain Whyte
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Iain Whyte
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Iain Whyte
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Kevin Lang
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Danny Aston
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Danny Aston
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Danny Aston
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Danny Aston
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Christopher Cowdy
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Ross McKenzie
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Jule Bandel
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Iain Whyte
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Christopher Cowdy
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Kevin Lang
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Danny Aston
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Iain Whyte
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Iain Whyte
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Martin Scott
									Agenda item : 
									7.2 Response to Motion by Councillor Booth - Rainbow Bridge/Lindsay Road Bridge – Report by the Executive Director of Place								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
									7.4 Response to Motion by Councillor McVey - Trams to Newhaven Progress Update Autumn 2022 – Report by the Executive Director of Place								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Iain Whyte
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Danny Aston
- 
											Cllr Danny Aston
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Ross McKenzie
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Danny Aston
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Martin Scott
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Martin Scott
									Agenda item : 
									7.5 Response to Motion by Councillor Whyte – Cleaning Up Edinburgh (Communal Bin Review Update) – Report by the Executive Director of Place								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Jule Bandel
- 
											Cllr Jule Bandel
- 
											Cllr Jule Bandel
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Sanne Dijkstra-Downie
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Sanne Dijkstra-Downie
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Iain Whyte
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Iain Whyte
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Iain Whyte
- 
											Gareth Barwell
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Jule Bandel
- 
											Cllr Jule Bandel
- 
											Gareth Barwell
- 
											Cllr Jule Bandel
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Ross McKenzie
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Danny Aston
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Iain Whyte
- 
											Cllr Christopher Cowdy
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Iain Whyte
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Jule Bandel
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Martin Scott
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Martin Scott
- 
											Cllr Iain Whyte
- 
											Martin Scott
- 
											Martin Scott
- 
											Cllr Iain Whyte
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Iain Whyte
- 
											Martin Scott
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Martin Scott
- 
											Cllr Danny Aston
- 
											Martin Scott
- 
											Cllr Jule Bandel
- 
											Cllr Christopher Cowdy
- 
											Martin Scott
- 
											Cllr Sanne Dijkstra-Downie
- 
											Martin Scott
- 
											Cllr Kevin Lang
- 
											Martin Scott
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Ross McKenzie
- 
											Martin Scott
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Martin Scott
- 
											Cllr Iain Whyte
- 
											Martin Scott
- 
											Cllr Norman Work
- 
											Martin Scott
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
									Agenda item : 
									7.5 Response to Motion by Councillor Whyte – Cleaning Up Edinburgh (Communal Bin Review Update) – Report by the Executive Director of Place								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Martin Scott
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Martin Scott
									Agenda item : 
									4. Minutes								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Martin Scott
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Iain Whyte
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Iain Whyte
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Martin Scott
									Agenda item : 
									5. Forward Planning								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Iain Whyte
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Kevin Lang
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Martin Scott
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Kevin Lang
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Sanne Dijkstra-Downie
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Gareth Barwell
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Martin Scott
									Agenda item : 
									6. Business Bulletin								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Iain Whyte
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Danny Aston
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Martin Scott
									Agenda item : 
									7.3 Response to Motion by Councillor McVey – North Bridge - Report by the Executive Director of Place								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Danny Aston
- 
											Gareth Barwell
- 
											Gareth Barwell
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Ross McKenzie
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Jule Bandel
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Martin Scott
									Agenda item : 
									7.6 Cleaning Up Edinburgh – Motion by Councillor Whyte – Report by the Executive Director of Place								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Gareth Barwell
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Kevin Lang
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Gareth Barwell
- 
											Cllr Kevin Lang
- 
											Gareth Barwell
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Ross McKenzie
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Gareth Barwell
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Iain Whyte
- 
											Gareth Barwell
- 
											Gareth Barwell
- 
											Cllr Christopher Cowdy
- 
											Gareth Barwell
- 
											Gareth Barwell
- 
											Cllr Jule Bandel
- 
											Cllr Jule Bandel
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Ross McKenzie
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Kevin Lang
- 
											Cllr Sanne Dijkstra-Downie
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Jule Bandel
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Iain Whyte
- 
											Cllr Christopher Cowdy
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Christopher Cowdy
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Iain Whyte
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Martin Scott
									Agenda item : 
									7.7 Concessionary Travel on Edinburgh Trams for Young People (Under 22) – Report by the Executive Director of Place								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Danny Aston
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Ross McKenzie
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Danny Aston
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Sanne Dijkstra-Downie
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Jule Bandel
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Iain Whyte
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Christopher Cowdy
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Kevin Lang
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Kevin Lang
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Danny Aston
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Martin Scott
									Agenda item : 
									7.8 Asset Transfer – Ex-City Development Assets – Report by the Executive Director of Place								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Martin Scott
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Martin Scott
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Martin Scott
- 
											Cllr Jule Bandel
- 
											Martin Scott
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Martin Scott
- 
											Cllr Ross McKenzie
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Martin Scott
- 
											Cllr Jule Bandel
- 
											Martin Scott
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Martin Scott
- 
											Martin Scott
									Agenda item : 
									8.1 Risk Based Approach to Road Asset Safety Inspections – Update – Report by the Executive Director of Place								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Gareth Barwell
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Gareth Barwell
- 
											Cllr Danny Aston
- 
											Gareth Barwell
- 
											Cllr Danny Aston
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Martin Scott
									Agenda item : 
									8.2 Revenue Monitoring Update – 2021/22 Provisional out-turn and								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Martin Scott
									Agenda item : 
									9.1 Motion by Councillor Arthur – Burnside Bridge								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Ross McKenzie
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Danny Aston
- 
											Cllr Norman Work
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Danny Aston
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Martin Scott
									Agenda item : 
									9.2 Motion by Councillor Aston – McGill’s takeover of First East Coast’s 20, 63 and 68 services								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Danny Aston
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Danny Aston
- 
											Cllr Norman Work
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Danny Aston
									Agenda item : 
									9.3 Motion by Councillor Aston – Electric Scooters								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Finlay McFarlane
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Ross McKenzie
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Sanne Dijkstra-Downie
- 
											Cllr Kevin Lang
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Jule Bandel
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Cllr Danny Aston
- 
											Cllr Scott Arthur
- 
											Webcast Finished
 
																									
															Scottish Labour														
													 
																									
															Scottish National Party														
													 
																									
															Scottish Green Party														
													 
																									 
																									
															Scottish Green Party														
													 
																									
															Scottish Liberal Democrats														
													 
																									
															Scottish Conservatives														
													 
																									
															Scottish Liberal Democrats														
													 
																									
															Scottish Liberal Democrats														
													 
																									 
																									
															Scottish National Party														
													 
																									
															Scottish Labour														
													 
																									
															Scottish Green Party														
													 
																									
															Commitee services														
													 
																									
															Scottish Conservatives														
													 
																									
															Scottish National Party