Transport and Environment Committee - Thursday 16 November 2023, 10:00am - City of Edinburgh Council Webcasts
Transport and Environment Committee
Thursday, 16th November 2023 at 10:00am
Speaking:
Agenda item :
Start of webcast
Share this agenda point
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Carolanne Eyre
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Carolanne Eyre
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Carolanne Eyre
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
Agenda item :
1. Order of Business
Share this agenda point
Agenda item :
1 a) Order of Business
Share this agenda point
-
Carolanne Eyre
-
Rachel Gentleman
Agenda item :
2. Declaration of Interests
Share this agenda point
Agenda item :
2 a) Declaration of Interests
Share this agenda point
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Kevin Lang
-
Rachel Gentleman
Agenda item :
3. Deputations
Share this agenda point
Agenda item :
3 a) Deputations
Share this agenda point
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Joanna Mowat
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Marie-Clair Munro
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Kevin Lang
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Chas Booth
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Catherine Fullerton
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Danny Aston
-
Cllr Danny Aston
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Kevin Lang
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Kevin Lang
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Marie-Clair Munro
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Marie-Clair Munro
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Catherine Fullerton
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Catherine Fullerton
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Kevin Lang
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Max Mitchell
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
Agenda item :
3 a) Deputations
Share this agenda point
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Rachel Gentleman
Agenda item :
4. Minutes
Share this agenda point
Agenda item :
4 a) Minutes
Agenda item :
5. Forward Planning
Share this agenda point
Agenda item :
5 a) Work Programme
Share this agenda point
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Stuart Dobbin
Agenda item :
5 b) Rolling Actions Log
Share this agenda point
-
Gareth Barwell (Service Director- Operational Services)
-
Cllr Stuart Dobbin
-
Gareth Barwell (Service Director- Operational Services)
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
Agenda item :
6. Business Bulletin
Share this agenda point
Agenda item :
6 a) Business Bulletin
Share this agenda point
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Danny Aston
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Hannah Ross
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Christopher Cowdy
-
Hannah Ross
-
Cllr Christopher Cowdy
-
Hannah Ross
-
Cllr Christopher Cowdy
-
Cllr Katrina Faccenda
-
Hannah Ross
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Marie-Clair Munro
-
Daisy Narayanan
-
Cllr Marie-Clair Munro
-
Daisy Narayanan
-
Cllr Marie-Clair Munro
-
Daisy Narayanan
-
Cllr Marie-Clair Munro
-
Daisy Narayanan
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Danny Aston
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Christopher Cowdy
-
Daisy Narayanan
-
Cllr Christopher Cowdy
-
Daisy Narayanan
-
Cllr Christopher Cowdy
-
Daisy Narayanan
-
Cllr Kevin Lang
-
Daisy Narayanan
-
Cllr Kevin Lang
-
Daisy Narayanan
-
Paul Lawrence (Executive Director of Place)
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Christopher Cowdy
-
Cllr Christopher Cowdy
-
Cllr Christopher Cowdy
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Danny Aston
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Danny Aston
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Kevin Lang
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
Agenda item :
7. Executive Decisions
Share this agenda point
Agenda item :
7 a) Response to the Edinburgh Tram Inquiry
Share this agenda point
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Hannah Ross
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Christopher Cowdy
-
Hannah Ross
-
Paul Lawrence (Executive Director of Place)
-
Cllr Christopher Cowdy
-
Hannah Ross
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Danny Aston
-
Hannah Ross
-
Paul Lawrence (Executive Director of Place)
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Paul Lawrence (Executive Director of Place)
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Paul Lawrence (Executive Director of Place)
-
Gavin King (Democracy, Governance and Resilience Senior
-
Cllr Danny Aston
-
Hannah Ross
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Marie-Clair Munro
-
Hannah Ross
-
Gavin King (Democracy, Governance and Resilience Senior
-
Hannah Ross
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Sanne Dijkstra-Downie
-
Hannah Ross
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Chas Booth
-
Hannah Ross
-
Cllr Chas Booth
-
Hannah Ross
-
Paul Lawrence (Executive Director of Place)
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Katrina Faccenda
-
Paul Lawrence (Executive Director of Place)
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Kevin Lang
-
Paul Lawrence (Executive Director of Place)
-
Hannah Ross
-
Cllr Kevin Lang
-
Hannah Ross
-
Paul Lawrence (Executive Director of Place)
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Christopher Cowdy
-
Hannah Ross
-
Cllr Christopher Cowdy
-
Hannah Ross
-
Cllr Christopher Cowdy
-
Hannah Ross
-
Paul Lawrence (Executive Director of Place)
-
Cllr Christopher Cowdy
-
Hannah Ross
-
Cllr Christopher Cowdy
-
Hannah Ross
-
Cllr Christopher Cowdy
-
Hannah Ross
-
Cllr Christopher Cowdy
-
Paul Lawrence (Executive Director of Place)
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Gavin King (Democracy, Governance and Resilience Senior
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Gavin King (Democracy, Governance and Resilience Senior
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Paul Lawrence (Executive Director of Place)
-
Cllr Marie-Clair Munro
-
Hannah Ross
-
Gavin King (Democracy, Governance and Resilience Senior
-
Cllr Catherine Fullerton
-
Gavin King (Democracy, Governance and Resilience Senior
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Chas Booth
-
Hannah Ross
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Chas Booth
-
Cllr Danny Aston
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Stuart Dobbin
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Marie-Clair Munro
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Kevin Lang
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
Agenda item :
7 a) Response to the Edinburgh Tram Inquiry
Share this agenda point
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Rachel Gentleman
Agenda item :
8 e) Implementing the new Parking Prohibitions
Share this agenda point
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Sanne Dijkstra-Downie
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Sanne Dijkstra-Downie
-
Cllr Sanne Dijkstra-Downie
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Marie-Clair Munro
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Kevin Lang
-
Cllr Kevin Lang
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Christopher Cowdy
-
Cllr Christopher Cowdy
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Danny Aston
-
Cllr Danny Aston
-
Paul Lawrence (Executive Director of Place)
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Kayleigh O'Neill
-
Cllr Kayleigh O'Neill
-
Cllr Kayleigh O'Neill
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Catherine Fullerton
-
Cllr Catherine Fullerton
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Gareth Barwell (Service Director- Operational Services)
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Gareth Barwell (Service Director- Operational Services)
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Gareth Barwell (Service Director- Operational Services)
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Katrina Faccenda
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Kevin Lang
-
Gareth Barwell (Service Director- Operational Services)
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Kevin Lang
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Gareth Barwell (Service Director- Operational Services)
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Katrina Faccenda
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Danny Aston
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Kevin Lang
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Kayleigh O'Neill
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Chas Booth
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Danny Aston
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Danny Aston
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Rachel Gentleman
Agenda item :
8 f) Supported Bus Services
Share this agenda point
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Danny Aston
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Daisy Narayanan
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Danny Aston
-
Daisy Narayanan
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Kevin Lang
-
Daisy Narayanan
-
Paul Lawrence (Executive Director of Place)
-
Cllr Kevin Lang
-
Daisy Narayanan
-
Paul Lawrence (Executive Director of Place)
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Chas Booth
-
Daisy Narayanan
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Daisy Narayanan
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Chas Booth
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Christopher Cowdy
-
Cllr Christopher Cowdy
-
Cllr Christopher Cowdy
-
Cllr Christopher Cowdy
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Sanne Dijkstra-Downie
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Paul Lawrence (Executive Director of Place)
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Chas Booth
-
Daisy Narayanan
-
Paul Lawrence (Executive Director of Place)
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Katrina Faccenda
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Danny Aston
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Christopher Cowdy
-
Cllr Christopher Cowdy
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Kevin Lang
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Chas Booth
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
Agenda item :
8 f) Supported Bus Services
Share this agenda point
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Chas Booth
-
Cllr Christopher Cowdy
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Kevin Lang
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Rachel Gentleman
Agenda item :
7 b) Travelling Safely Schemes
Share this agenda point
-
Daisy Narayanan
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Marie-Clair Munro
-
Daisy Narayanan
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Katrina Faccenda
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Danny Aston
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Kevin Lang
-
Cllr Sanne Dijkstra-Downie
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Kayleigh O'Neill
-
Cllr Chas Booth
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Marie-Clair Munro
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Rachel Gentleman
Agenda item :
7 c) Public Toilets
Share this agenda point
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Cllr Marie-Clair Munro
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Marie-Clair Munro
-
Cllr Danny Aston
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Katrina Faccenda
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Kayleigh O'Neill
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Catherine Fullerton
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Rachel Gentleman
Agenda item :
7 d) Parking Permits for Places of Worship
Share this agenda point
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Katrina Faccenda
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Rachel Gentleman
Agenda item :
7 e) Bus Lane Penalty Charge Levels
Share this agenda point
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Marie-Clair Munro
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Marie-Clair Munro
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Kevin Lang
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Danny Aston
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Christopher Cowdy
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Chas Booth
-
Cllr Chas Booth
-
Cllr Chas Booth
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Catherine Fullerton
-
Cllr Catherine Fullerton
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Stuart Dobbin
-
Cllr Stuart Dobbin
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Katrina Faccenda
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Chas Booth
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Rachel Gentleman
Agenda item :
8. Routine Decisions
Share this agenda point
Agenda item :
8 a) Public Utility Company Performance and Road Work Co-ordination April 2022 to March 2023
Share this agenda point
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Sanne Dijkstra-Downie
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Kevin Lang
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Chas Booth
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
Agenda item :
8 b) Granton Waterfront – Investigation of Parking Controls - Update
Share this agenda point
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Katrina Faccenda
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Kevin Lang
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Kayleigh O'Neill
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Cllr Kayleigh O'Neill
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Cllr Kayleigh O'Neill
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Sanne Dijkstra-Downie
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Cllr Sanne Dijkstra-Downie
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Cllr Kayleigh O'Neill
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Rachel Gentleman
Agenda item :
8 c) Communal Bin Review Update
Share this agenda point
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Sanne Dijkstra-Downie
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Marie-Clair Munro
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Rachel Gentleman
Agenda item :
8 d) Cleansing Performance Report
Share this agenda point
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Katrina Faccenda
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Kevin Lang
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Rachel Gentleman
Agenda item :
9. Motions
Share this agenda point
Agenda item :
9 a) Motion by Councillor Davidson - Corstorphine Connections
Share this agenda point
-
Cllr Kevin Lang
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Cllr Danny Aston
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Rachel Gentleman
Agenda item :
9 b) Motion by Councillor Heap - Westfield Street Parking
Share this agenda point
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Kayleigh O'Neill
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Katrina Faccenda
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Rachel Gentleman
Agenda item :
9 c) Motion by Councillor Aston - Skip Permits
Share this agenda point
-
Cllr Danny Aston
-
Rachel Gentleman
Agenda item :
9 d) Motion by Councillor Cowdy - Dog Fouling
Share this agenda point
-
Cllr Christopher Cowdy
-
Cllr Marie-Clair Munro
-
Cllr Chas Booth
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
Agenda item :
9 e) Motion by Councillor Munro - New Style Bus Trackers
Share this agenda point
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Cllr Marie-Clair Munro
-
Cllr Danny Aston
-
Cllr Kayleigh O'Neill
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Cllr Katrina Faccenda
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Cllr Scott Arthur
-
Rachel Gentleman
-
Webcast Finished
- 05 Minute 12.10.23, opens in new tab
- Work Programme, opens in new tab
- Rolling Actions Log, opens in new tab
- Item 6.1 - Business Bulletin, opens in new tab
- Response to Tram Inquiry with appendices 1 to 3, opens in new tab
- Item 7.2 - Travelling Safely Schemes, opens in new tab
- Item 7.3 - Public Toilets, opens in new tab
- Item 7.4 - Parking Permits for Places of Worship, opens in new tab
- Item 7.5 - Bus Lane Penalty Charge Levels, opens in new tab
- Item 8.1 - Public Utility Company Performance 2022 - 2023, opens in new tab
- Item 8.2 - Granton Waterfront - Investigation of Parking Controls Update, opens in new tab
- Item 8.3 - Communal Bin Review Update, opens in new tab
- Item 8.4 - Cleansing Performance Update, opens in new tab
- Item 8.5 - Implementing new parking prohibitions, opens in new tab
- Item 8.6 - Supported Bus Services, opens in new tab
- Deputations Pack v3, opens in new tab
- Motions and Amendments - T&E Committee - 16 Nov 2023, opens in new tab
![](http://cl-assets.public-i.tv/_client_level_data/236/photos/s_sp_photo_1652701933182d5ffeab.png)
Scottish Labour
![](http://cl-assets.public-i.tv/_client_level_data/236/photos/s_sp_photo_16527015591bcfe37232.png)
Scottish National Party
![](http://cl-assets.public-i.tv/_client_level_data/all/photos/s_noprofile.jpg)
![](http://cl-assets.public-i.tv/_client_level_data/236/photos/s_sp_photo_1652701936b5078056d9.png)
Scottish Green Party
![](http://cl-assets.public-i.tv/_client_level_data/236/photos/s_sp_photo_1652701941c3792882e9.png)
Scottish Conservatives
![](http://cl-assets.public-i.tv/_client_level_data/236/photos/s_sp_photo_1652701944c12e0a9d51.png)
Scottish Liberal Democrats
![](http://cl-assets.public-i.tv/_client_level_data/236/photos/s_sp_photo_16527019451cfc927d66.png)
Scottish National Party
![](http://cl-assets.public-i.tv/_client_level_data/236/photos/s_sp_photo_1652701948f1bd99aef5.png)
Scottish National Party
![](http://cl-assets.public-i.tv/_client_level_data/all/photos/s_noprofile.jpg)
![](http://cl-assets.public-i.tv/_client_level_data/236/photos/s_sp_photo_165270195698fbf365f3.png)
Scottish Liberal Democrats
![](http://cl-assets.public-i.tv/_client_level_data/all/photos/s_noprofile.jpg)
![](http://cl-assets.public-i.tv/_client_level_data/236/photos/s_sp_photo_165270196106eb787b8c.png)
Scottish Conservatives
![](http://cl-assets.public-i.tv/_client_level_data/236/photos/s_sp_photo_165270196286f03284e9.png)
Scottish Conservatives
![](http://cl-assets.public-i.tv/_client_level_data/236/photos/s_sp_photo_1652701963f90bf9f6b7.png)
Scottish Conservatives
![](http://cl-assets.public-i.tv/_client_level_data/236/photos/s_sp_photo_165270196497130eeb56.png)
Scottish Green Party