Governance, Risk and Best Value Committee - Tuesday 14 March 2023, 10:00am - Start video at 2:02:24 - City of Edinburgh Council Webcasts
			Governance, Risk and Best Value Committee
Tuesday, 14th March 2023 at 10:00am 
		
			Speaking:  
				
					
									Agenda item : 
									Start of webcast								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
									Agenda item : 
									1. Order of Business								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Emily Traynor
									Agenda item : 
									1 a) Order of Business								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Katrina Faccenda
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Katrina Faccenda
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Katrina Faccenda
- 
											Emily Traynor
- 
											Cllr Katrina Faccenda
- 
											Emily Traynor
									Agenda item : 
									2. Declaration of Interests								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
									2 a) Declaration of Interests								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
													
							- 
											Emily Traynor
									Agenda item : 
									3. Deputations								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
									3 a) Deputations								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
									4. Minutes								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
									4 a) Minutes								
							
									Agenda item : 
									5. Outstanding Actions								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
									5 a) Outstanding Actions								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Emily Traynor
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
									Agenda item : 
									6. Work Programme								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
									6 a) Work Programme								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Emily Traynor
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
									Agenda item : 
									7. Business Bulletin								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
									7 a) Business Bulletin								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Emily Traynor
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Emily Traynor
									Agenda item : 
									8. Reports								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
						
											
									Agenda item : 
									8 a) Internal Audit: 2023/24 Internal Audit Annual Plan - report by the Head of Internal Audit								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Katrina Faccenda
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
									Agenda item : 
									8 a) Internal Audit: 2023/24 Internal Audit Annual Plan - report by the Head of Internal Audit								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Lewis Younie
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Katrina Faccenda
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Emily Traynor
									Agenda item : 
									8 b) Internal Audit: Internal Audit Charter Annual Update - report by the Head of Internal Audit								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Lewis Younie
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Emily Traynor
									Agenda item : 
									8 c) Change Portfolio								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Jule Bandel
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Stephen Jenkinson
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Lewis Younie
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Lewis Younie
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Katrina Faccenda
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Emily Traynor
									Agenda item : 
									8 d) Annual Assurance Schedule - Corporate Services								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Emily Traynor
									Agenda item : 
									8 e) Annual Assurance Schedule - Place Directorate								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
									Agenda item : 
									8 f) Gas Service Improvement Plan Closure Report								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Emily Traynor
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Emily Traynor
									Agenda item : 
									8 g) Procurement of Edinburgh’s Christmas – referral from the Finance and Resources Committee								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Katrina Faccenda
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
									Agenda item : 
									8 h) Revenue Monitoring 2022/23 – month eight position – referral from the Finance and Resources Committee								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Emily Traynor
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Emily Traynor
									Agenda item : 
									8 i) Capital Monitoring 2022/23 – month eight position – referral from the Finance and Resources Committee								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
									Agenda item : 
									8 j) Sustainable Capital Budget Strategy 2023-2033 – referral from the Finance and Resources Committee								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Emily Traynor
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Lewis Younie
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Marco Biagi
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Jamie Macrae (Clerk)
- 
											Emily Traynor
- 
											Jamie Macrae (Clerk)
- 
											Emily Traynor
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
									Agenda item : 
									8 j) Sustainable Capital Budget Strategy 2023-2033 – referral from the Finance and Resources Committee								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Emily Traynor
									Agenda item : 
									8 k) Accounts Commission: Local Government in Scotland – Financial Bulletin 2021/22 – referral from the Finance and Resources Committee								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Emily Traynor
									Agenda item : 
									8 l) Treasury Management: Mid-Year Report 2022/23 - referral from the City of Edinburgh Council								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Stephen Jenkinson
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Emily Traynor
									Agenda item : 
									8 m) Capital Theatres Company Performance Report 2021/22 – referral from the Culture and Communities Committee								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Stephen Jenkinson
- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Emily Traynor
									Agenda item : 
									8 n) Update on Council Transport Arms Length Companies – referral from the Transport and Environment Committee								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Paul Lawrence
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
									Agenda item : 
									8 o) Drumbrae Care Home – status report								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Emily Traynor
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Katrina Faccenda
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Marco Biagi
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Claire Miller
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Jule Bandel
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
									Agenda item : 
									8 p) Whistleblowing update								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Emily Traynor
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Joanna Mowat
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
									Agenda item : 
									8 q) Whistleblowing Annual Report 2022								
							
								Share this agenda point								
							
						
													
							
						
													
							- 
											Emily Traynor
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Cllr Kate Campbell
- 
											Emily Traynor
- 
											Webcast Finished
- 4.1 - Minute of 24 January 2023, opens in new tab
- 5.1 Outstanding Actions - 14 March 2023, opens in new tab
- 6.1 Work Programme - 14 March 2023, opens in new tab
- 6.1 Upcoming Reports - 14 March 2023, opens in new tab
- 7.1 Business Bulletin, opens in new tab
- 8.1 Internal Audit 202324 Internal Audit Annual Plan, opens in new tab
- 8.2 Internal Audit Internal Audit Charter Annual Update, opens in new tab
- 8.3 Change Portfolio, opens in new tab
- 8.4 Annual Assurance Schedule – Corporate Services, opens in new tab
- 8.5 Annual Assurance Schedule – Place Directorate, opens in new tab
- 8.6 Gas Service Improvement Plan Closure Report, opens in new tab
- 8.7 Procurement of Edinburgh's Christmas - referral to GRBV from F&R, opens in new tab
- 8.8 Revenue Monitoring 202223 – month eight position - referral to GRBV from F&R, opens in new tab
- 8.9 Capital Monitoring 202223 – month eight position - referral to GRBV from F&R, opens in new tab
- 8.10 Sustainable Capital Budget Strategy 2023-2033 referral to GRBV from F&R, opens in new tab
- 8.11 Accounts Commission Local Government in Scotland – referral to GRBV from F&R, opens in new tab
- 8.12 Treasury Management Mid-Year Report 2022-23 - referral to GRBV from the City of Edinburgh Council, opens in new tab
- 8.13 Capital Theatres Company Performance Report 202122 – referral from the Culture and Communities Committee, opens in new tab
- 8.14 Update on Council Transport Arms Length Companies - referral to GRBV from TEC, opens in new tab
- 8.15 Drumbrae Care Home – status report, opens in new tab
- 8.17 Whistleblowing update, opens in new tab
- 8.18 Whistleblowing Annual Report 2022, opens in new tab
- Emergency Motion by Councillor Campbell - Budget Setting Process, opens in new tab
- Motions and Amendments - GRBV - 14.03.23, opens in new tab
 
																									
															Scottish Green Party														
													 
																									
															Scottish National Party														
													 
																									
															Scottish National Party														
													 
																									
															Scottish Labour														
													 
																									
															Scottish Labour														
													 
																									 
																									
															Scottish Green Party														
													 
																									
															Scottish Conservatives														
													 
																									
															Scottish Liberal Democrats